Yesterday
the BBC broke a story about thirty three girls who have
apparently disappeared from schools in Bradford authorities
suspect that the girls have been taken abroad to be
forcefully married.
What makes this and stories of forced marriages and
honor violence shocking is that it is not the traditional
mindset of first generation immigrants, but one that
has infiltrated into second generation British Asian
and Muslim as well. Crimes against those who refuse
to marry out of force. Estimates by Reunite are that
around 1,000 women are subjected to forced marriages
annually in the UK (this excludes the large proportion
of men helped by the Foreign Office’s Forced Marriages
Unit.)
In my quest for more knowledge, I decided to speak
to Nazir Afzal, Director of West London Crown Prosecution
Service about the issue. Nazir’s work in this
area began in 2004; his aim was not merely to raise
awareness about this issue, but also to develop strategies
to deal with such crimes. Being tactically placed, with
access to senior police officials and Ministers, Nazir
has not only been in a position to prevent these crimes
from taking place, but also to help prosecute perpetrators
guilty of such acts of violence.
Without wanting to justify the motives or actions of
those responsible, Nazir claims that the perpetrators
are often victims of society themselves who succumb
to social, cultural and family pressure. He disagrees
that the problem is linked to strict religious ideologies
within the Muslim community, “this behavior by
no means makes this a religiously induced problem, the
causes range from ignorance to a lack of information”
he assures me, “mosques are now beginning to talk
about it, but even they feel threatened by the community.”
But does the problem have its roots in doctrine that
promotes forced marriages and justifies violence for
the sake of honor? There are approximately 1.5 million
Muslims in the UK today, around 74% of whom are of Asian
origin - predominantly Pakistani at 43% - of this community,
around 50% are from Azad Kashmir (Mirpur and Kotli)
– these are groups who have undergone chain-migration,
and emulate a particular lifestyle from the Indian Subcontinent.
Second, there is the issue of low attainment and high
unemployment which both contribute to overall social
well-being. The Muslim community has a working age population
of around 60%, the unemployment rate is almost 18% (the
current UK unemployment rate being 4.3%). Together,
the Pakistani and Bangladeshi community also has a combined
working population of around 60% - the unemployment
rate is around 17% amongst Pakistanis and approximately
20% amongst Bangladeshis.
Educationally, around 33% Muslims have no qualifications.
Out of this group, Pakistani and Bangladeshi boys have
the lowest rate of basic qualifications (NVQ Level 2
or GCSEs). The percentage of those with no qualifications
in the UK is around 15%.
To add to this, Asian and Muslim communities tend to
group together and often reside in shared accommodation
– this continues after marriage to maintain the
traditional “joint family system”, though
around 32% of Muslim households experience overcrowding,
with Hindu and Sikh households experiencing around 22%
and 19% respectively.*
These are all are interlinked factors and contribute
towards general social status, acceptance and awareness.
In terms of marriage, Asian communities group together
to maintain social and religious cohesion and a sense
of identity - which can lead to a notion of preserving
one’s “natural identity”. Women are
mainly seen as the “honor” of the family
and are encouraged to nurture a sense of cultural identity
- and so if they decide to lead a life independent of
cultural limitations, particularly with regard to marriage,
they are often ostracised.
These are all factors which undoubtedly add to slow-progression
and persisting ago-old feudal mentality amongst some
within these communities. Until these social causal
factors are addressed, little can be done to change
the perceptions amongst young Asians - but we must acknowledge
that this problem is not one that is linked to religious
ideology with its roots in Islam or any other established
religion.
Later this year, the government will bring into force
the Forced Marriages Act 2007 - a rather ‘delicate’
piece of legislation which aims to protect “individuals
against being forced to enter into marriage without
their free and full consent” - the Act does not
limit itself to force through means of violence, but
also methods which include psychological pressure -
a problem faced by a large proportion of young British
Asian adults, the majority of whom are bound by perpetual
indebtedness and ‘honour’ in the UK today.
Although welcomed by many enforcement bodies and community
leaders, the Act is essentially looking to reduce the
number of immigrant-marriages by force, a strategy which
seems more in line with current immigration limitation
plans, than to reduce forced marriages. It will not
abolish the long-standing tradition of emotional pressure,
nor will it, in my opinion, prohibit or deter crimes
committed in the name of honour.
*Data has been sourced from National Statistics Online.
|